What is an Election?
Elections are a fundamental aspect of democratic societies, allowing citizens to have a say in who governs them or makes decisions on their behalf. An election is a formal process where people choose someone for a particular position or represent them by voting. Elections can happen at various levels, from local community elections to national or even international Elections.
Types of Election in India?
Certainly! In India, four main types of elections play a crucial role in the democratic system:
1. General Elections (Lok Sabha): These elections occur once every five years. During general elections, all eligible voters exercise their voting rights to choose members of the Lok Sabha (House of the People). Candidates who win become “Members of Parliament” (MPs). So far, there have been 17 Loc Sabha General Elections.
2. State Assembly Elections: In these elections, voters directly choose members of their respective State Legislative Assemblies. The Chief Minister, who leads the party or political alliance with a majority in the state elections, exercises executive powers within the state. The governor may dissolve the assembly during the five-year term if necessary.
3. Rajya Sabha Elections: Only members of the State Legislative Assemblies have the right to vote in Rajya Sabha elections. Each Rajya Sabha member serves a six-year term, with one-third of the members changing every two years. The Rajya Sabha acts as a second-level review body during the legislative process1.
4. Local Body Elections: These elections occur once every two years and focus on electing local government officials such as mayors and councillors. Returning officers oversee municipal elections, ensuring local self-governance.
Overview
- Election methods and their types
- Paper Ballots
- Electronics Voting Machines (EVMs)
- History of election
- Paper ballots
- Transition to EVMs
- Introduction of NOTA
- Pros and Cons of Paper ballots and EVMs
Election methods and their types:
Paper Ballots-
Ballot paper voting refers to the traditional method of casting votes using physical paper ballots. Here's how it works:
1. Preparation of Ballot Papers:
- Before the election, ballot papers are printed with the names of candidates or parties contesting the election, along with their respective symbols or identifiers.
- Each ballot paper typically corresponds to a specific electoral constituency or voting district.
2. Voting Process:
- On Election Day, voters go to their designated polling stations where they are provided with a ballot paper.
- Voters enter a private voting booth or area to mark their choices on the ballot paper. This is usually done by placing a mark, cross, or other indication next to the chosen candidate's name or party.
- In some systems, voters may also rank candidates in order of preference.
3. Casting Votes:
- After marking their choices, voters fold the ballot paper to conceal their votes and place it in a sealed box.
4. Counting Votes:
- Once the voting period ends, election officials open the ballot boxes and manually count the votes recorded on each ballot paper.
- The votes for each candidate or party are tallied, and the results are compiled to determine the winner(s) of the election.
Electronic Voting Machine (EVMs):
Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) are sophisticated electronic devices used for casting and counting votes in elections. Here's a detailed breakdown of their components and how they work:
1. Control Unit (CU):
- The control unit is the main component of the EVM and controls the entire voting process.
- It consists of a microcontroller and memory for storing data related to the election.
- The CU is responsible for initializing the machine, activating the balloting unit, registering votes, and displaying results.
2. Balloting Unit (BU):
- The balloting unit is the interface through which voters cast their votes
- It contains buttons or symbols representing various candidates or parties contesting the election.
- Each button is assigned to a specific candidate or party, and voters select their choice by pressing the corresponding button.
3. Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT) (Optional):
- In some EVMs, a Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT) is integrated to provide a paper record of each vote cast.
- After a voter casts their vote electronically, the VVPAT generates a paper slip with the selected candidate's name, symbol, and serial number.
- The voter can verify the printed information through a transparent window before it drops into a sealed box, ensuring transparency and confidence in the voting process.
4. Battery and Security Features:
- EVMs are powered by batteries to ensure uninterrupted operation during elections.
- They are equipped with various security features to prevent tampering and ensure the integrity of the voting process.
- Security measures may include seals, locks, encryption, and special software to detect any unauthorized attempts to alter or manipulate the voting data.
5. Vote Counting and Result Display:
- Once the voting period ends, the EVMs are sealed to prevent any further votes from being cast.
- The control unit is then used to tally the votes recorded in the EVM's memory.
- The results are displayed either electronically on the control unit's screen or printed on paper (if VVPAT is used), summarising the votes received by each candidate or party.
History:
Certainly! Let’s delve into the fascinating history of voting methods in India, from traditional paper ballots to modern Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs).
- Paper Ballots:
- Ancient Roots: The use of paper ballots for elections dates back centuries. In Rome, around 139 BC, paper ballots were employed following the introduction of the lex Gabinia tabellaria.
- India’s Early Voting System: In Tamil Nadu, around 920 AD, palm leaves were used for village assembly elections. These palm leaves carried the names of candidates and were placed inside mud pots for counting. This system was known as the Kudavolai system.
- Challenges with Paper Ballots:
- Tedious and Time-Consuming: Paper ballots were cumbersome to handle. The process involved printing millions of ballots, transporting and storing them securely, and physically counting hundreds of millions of votes.
- Vulnerability to Rigging and Fraud: India faced issues like booth capturing, where criminals forcibly cast votes in favour of specific candidates. Reports of violence and voter fraud tainted the electoral process.
2. Transition to EVMs:
1982 Trial: In 1982, the Election Commission conducted a trial of Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) in the Paravur Assembly constituency in Kerala. This experiment replaced traditional paper ballots with EVMs in 50 out of 123 booths.
- Advantages of EVMs:
- Scale and Security: EVMs simplified the electoral process for India’s large democracy.
- Elimination of Tampering: EVMs reduced the risk of voter tampering and manipulation.
- Skepticism and Controversy:
- Over time, scepticism emerged regarding EVM transparency and reliability. Some questioned whether EVMs merely reproduced existing problems.
- Despite debates, EVMs have become an integral part of India's electroal process, with almost 55 lakh EVMs expected to be in circulation during the upcoming Lok Sabha Elections.
3.Introduction of NOTA:
NOTA (None of the Above) was introduced in 2013 as an option on EVMs.
- It allows voters to express dissatisfaction with all candidates by choosing NOTA instead of voting for any specific candidate.
- NOTA provides a way for citizens to participate even when they find none of the candidates suitable.
Both paper ballots and Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) have their advantages and disadvantages. Here's a comparison:
Paper Ballots:
Pros:
1. Transparency: Paper ballots are easily understandable by voters, and the counting process is transparent since it's physically visible.
2. Accessibility: Paper ballots are accessible to all voters, including those who may not be familiar with technology or who have disabilities.
3. Security: Paper ballots are less vulnerable to hacking or technical malfunctions compared to electronic systems.
4. Auditability: It's relatively straightforward to conduct manual recounts and audits of paper ballots, providing a way to verify election results.
Cons:
1. Time-Consuming: Counting paper ballots can be time-consuming, leading to delays in announcing election results.
2. Potential Errors: Manual counting can introduce errors, and the interpretation of voter intent may vary among election officials.
3. Storage Space: Paper ballots require adequate storage space, and there's a risk of physical damage or loss.
Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs):
Pros:
1. Speed: EVMs can expedite the voting process and reduce the time required for counting ballots, potentially providing faster election results.
2. Accuracy: EVMs can minimize errors associated with manual counting and reduce the risk of invalid votes due to unclear markings.
3. Space Efficiency: EVMs require less storage space for ballots compared to paper-based systems.
4. User Interface: EVMs can include features such as multilingual support and accessibility options for voters with disabilities.
Cons:
1. Security Concerns: EVMs can be vulnerable to hacking, tampering, or technical malfunctions, raising concerns about the integrity of election results.
2. Lack of Transparency: Some argue that EVMs lack transparency since voters cannot physically see their votes being recorded or verified.
3. Cost: EVMs can be expensive to procure, maintain, and update, especially for countries or regions with limited financial resources.
4. Dependence on Technology: EVMs rely on technology, which means they may be susceptible to power outages, software glitches, or other technical issues.
Ultimately, the choice between paper ballots and EVMs depends on various factors, including the preferences of election authorities, the level of trust in technology, the resources available, and the specific needs and challenges of the electoral process in a given context.
0 Comments